METHOD described the retired dispatch-time risk floor #149

New issue

Closed

opened 2026-08-15 14:33:47 +00:00 by john · 0 comments

john commented

2026-08-15 14:33:47 +00:00

Owner

Source: strict re-review C-09 (reviewed against v3.2.0)
Verdict: FIXED in v3.3.0 - closing

Claim as reviewed

METHOD still describes a retired dispatch-time risk/stakes floor, so current docs describe a mechanism current code removed.

At HEAD `f354864` (v3.3.0)

True when reviewed. Closed by v3.3.0, whose changelog names it: "METHOD.md and INTERNALS.md still described the dispatch-time risk floor and its per-surface waivers, both retired in v2.7.0".

Current text is a retirement notice, not a description: METHOD.md:420-422 - "Detection sets no floor. What a plan declares raises no level: the stakes you set is the whole of it. The dispatch-time detector ... were both cut in v2.7.0". cadence-core/bin/route.mjs:62-76 agrees.

Note

The review targeted commit 81bdb5d4fc on the v3.2.0 tree, one milestone behind HEAD.

**Source:** strict re-review C-09 (reviewed against v3.2.0) **Verdict:** FIXED in v3.3.0 - closing ### Claim as reviewed METHOD still describes a retired dispatch-time risk/stakes floor, so current docs describe a mechanism current code removed. ### At HEAD f354864 (v3.3.0) True when reviewed. Closed by v3.3.0, whose changelog names it: "`METHOD.md` and `INTERNALS.md` still described the dispatch-time risk floor and its per-surface waivers, both retired in v2.7.0". Current text is a retirement notice, not a description: `METHOD.md:420-422` - "**Detection sets no floor.** What a plan declares raises no level: the `stakes` you set is the whole of it. The dispatch-time detector ... were both cut in v2.7.0". `cadence-core/bin/route.mjs:62-76` agrees. ### Note The review targeted commit 81bdb5d4fc on the v3.2.0 tree, one milestone behind HEAD.